Mama Carolla's Indianapolis Yelp Reviews - Mama Carolla's Indianapolis - Kaufe eine Reservierung
Reservierung bei Mama Carolla's Indianapolis für Heute oder Morgen? Geht ganz Easy!
Kaufe eine verifizierte reservierung bei Mama Carolla's Indianapolis von Jemanden der sie nichtmehr braucht.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservierungs!
All listed Reservierungs are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
Indianapolis's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Mama Carolla's Indianapolis
Ranked #7 in Indianapolis's Best Restaurants.
Ranked #8 in Indianapolis's Best Restaurants.
Ranked #15 in Indianapolis's Best Restaurants.
Mama Carolla's Indianapolis Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
23 Reviews
0 Replys |
The ambiance of this little restaurant is calm and inviting.
It does kinda feel like you're in a little house in Italy. The food is beyond amazing!!! We got the pork braised special, Alfredo, Manicotti and pesto plates. All were delicious and I would highly recommend all of them! Overall, if you're wanting an amazing Italian dinner, this place is for you! Wish we lived closer because we would be regulars lol!
Be the first to ReplyDelicious food, great service, and a nice ambiance.
I'll definitely be back! I live a couple of hours away but will come back anytime I'm in Indy for a concert.
Be the first to ReplyReally good food and atmosphere.
I would've given it 5 stars 2 years ago, but the portions aren't what they used to be. Hence, the 4 star review. Food is delicious- I recommend the seafood pasta they have. No reservations for this location, so be ready to wait a bit. You can get a drink from the bar in meantime.
Be the first to ReplyI can't believe I waited so long to try this place.
The chicken piccata was amazing! I also loved the key lime and espresso martinis.
Be the first to ReplyAlways amazing food and service! I love the house and the
Always amazing food and service! I love the house and the atmosphere it creates! Countless times countless 5 star experiences
Be the first to ReplyI love mama carolla's always have always will.
This past experience wasn't good. I tried the Alfredo and it had a. Very off putting taste to it. Very herbal and grass like. Love the inside, love the service and always love the meals. For that, a 4/5 should be a 5/5 and it is. Love this restaurant to death, they just had a slight hiccup that night.
Be the first to ReplyMy wife and I recently took a friend here for her birthday.
We made reservations and ate outside, even though it was temporarily sealed against the cold. Very nice ambience, but the food was SO GOOD! I had the manicotti and we shared the appetizer Holly's Artichoke Fritters. Both were excellent. Wonderful place, and we enjoy the unchanged interior rooms. Oh yeah, the service was also very good.
Be the first to ReplyThis is my favorite restaurant in Indy.
The salmon with the dill sauce on the side is my go-to.
Be the first to ReplyThis place is amazing!!!! The food is truly authentic.
Atmosphere is beautiful. If you get lucky enough to have Rodney as a waiter you wont be disappointed! He is top notch. He made the entire night amazing!
Be the first to ReplyOne of my favorite Italian local restaurants in the city.
Variety of options. Best cocktail list I've ever seen. ( I like the foofoo martinis). The service every time I've been there is top notch.
Be the first to ReplyThe service, the intimate setting and the food is awesome.
It's as if Italy was at my back door. I started the meal with grilled shrimp, stuffed with goat cheese and a house salad. I opted for the Veal Saltimbocca once again, which has never disappointed. The veal was well seasoned, tender and not breaded (which is a plus), then smothered with prosciutto and a sauce that was worthy of dipping the warm crunchy bread in. Finished the meal with a decadent cannoli. Great experience...thank you Mama!!!
Be the first to ReplyThe food was great especially the garlic cheese bread.
Make sure you get there when they open because it gets really crowded. The service was attentive and fast. I would definitely eat there again. The restaurant's ambiance was nice.
Be the first to ReplyFinally got to Mama Carolla's after it being on my list for
Finally got to Mama Carolla's after it being on my list for a while. Great location right at 54th and the Monon. Phenomenal ambiance. Parking is a bit lacking but there's a few spots up front, a paid lot in the back, and then residential streets you can park on. They take reservations except for Friday/Saturday. We went without a reservation at 6 on a Thursday and had about a 30 minute wait.I ordered the chicken parm and my friend got the rosemary chicken lasagna. Both were great! Large portions so come hungry. We also got the spumoni which was amazing! It's covered in a chocolate shell. Pricing is extremely reasonable for food and wine. Didn't look to closely at the cocktail list. Awesome date spot and family restaurant all in 1.
Be the first to ReplyWe called and it was an hour wait last Saturday for a party
We called and it was an hour wait last Saturday for a party of 3, so we decided to do carryout. The process was so quick and easy over the phone, and the food was ready early! We got 3 Caesar Salads, Chicken Alfredo, Shrimp Alfredo, and spaghetti bolognese. It was DELICIOUS. The food is a little high in our budget, but everything was so good and so worth it. Definitely consider splitting an entree if you aren't a big eater, it's like 2 meals in one per dish. Only complaint would be that there were only 5 small shrimp in the shrimp Alfredo, and we expected more for what we paid. I have been in person before, but my parents have not, so we are looking forward to dining in next time they are in town!
Be the first to ReplyWonderful atmosphere and food!! Service was excellent!!
Wonderful atmosphere and food!! Service was excellent!! We had chicken parmigiana, ravioli and the gelato was so creamy.
Be the first to ReplyI recommend you to go to Mama Carolla's, the food is so
I recommend you to go to Mama Carolla's, the food is so delicious. The wait is a little long but it's worth it!! I loved the salad.
Be the first to ReplyAbsolutely the best Italian.
. The wait staff is exceptional food is high quality.. All homemade with exception of the pasta.Ambiance is very romantic for a couple.Had the fried ravioli and did not disappoint.You must get the chicken parmesan as an entre. not long for over 4 people.. Over 7 call for a reservation.Parking sucks.. Its not mamas fault.. The adjacent lot is now a pay lot. There is a few free spots.
Be the first to ReplyNice homely atmosphere, my gf pasta was to die for.
I had Italian food after a decade because no one gets gluten free past right!
Be the first to ReplyWhile visiting Indianapolis, we made a stop at Mama
While visiting Indianapolis, we made a stop at Mama Carolla's and it did not disappoint! This was my second time going and both times have been very pleasant. The first visit we sat on the patio but this time we dined inside. I love the coziness of being in a house but the seating we had was in a very small room with only a few tables so it felt like your were eavesdropping on each others conversations which felt a bit distracting. We also had to wait quite a significant amount of time to be seated even with a reservation. We had a bottle of wine, each ordered a pasta that came with salad or soup. Each of us enjoyed what we ordered and I would definitely return but would hope to have a better table placement.
Be the first to ReplyMama Carollas is our go-to date night restaurant! We love
Mama Carollas is our go-to date night restaurant! We love coming here for the quaint, cozy atmosphere. You truly feel like you're eating a delicious home cooked meal. My favorite is chicken involtine, it never gets old. It's creamy and delicious. My boyfriend typically orders whatever the special is, and he's never been disappointed. Pro tip: add your name to the waitlist online before heading over!
Be the first to ReplyI absolutely love Mama Carolla's.
The food is always amazing and the atmosphere and service is amazing as well. It feels very family orientated when you are sitting at the table preparing to enjoy the amazing food and service:)
Be the first to ReplyThis place is amazing.
The food, the service, the atmosphere. There's a reason it's a must-try in Indy! The only issue of late is the parking situation, but once you're inside and seated, you forget everything before that.
Be the first to ReplyThe ambiance and food are amazing! The restaurant is an old
The ambiance and food are amazing! The restaurant is an old house turned into the restaurant. Would highly recommend
Be the first to Reply