Cosimo's Poughkeepsie Yelp Reviews - Cosimo's Poughkeepsie - Kaufe eine Reservierung
Reservierung bei Cosimo's Poughkeepsie für Heute oder Morgen? Geht ganz Easy!
Kaufe eine verifizierte reservierung bei Cosimo's Poughkeepsie von Jemanden der sie nichtmehr braucht.
If there is nothing that fits your schedule, you can bid on your preferred time.
We only list verified Reservierungs!
All listed Reservierungs are reviewed by our team before appearing in the calendar or being allowed to answer a bid you place. That's why AppointmentTrader comes with a included Money Back Guarantee for each transaction.
Poughkeepsie's Best Restaurants that are most frequently booked by customers of Cosimo's Poughkeepsie
Cosimo's Poughkeepsie Yelp Reviews
Latest Reviews On Yelp
32 Reviews
0 Replys |
Food was Meh, service good, my tiramisu was probably the
Food was Meh, service good, my tiramisu was probably the best I've ever had. Crème Brulee not creamy or very flavorful. I mean nothing stood where I was in taste heaven. Ambiance nice,. This is my take mind you. I hope your ordered food makes you want to go back for more ..., maybe for the shrimp cappellini pasta That was tasty. I almost forgot- question when you order bruschetta, would expect little slices of baguette with chopped tomatoes, mozzarella. This was ONE slice of bread with schmutts dumped on it! And she gives me a knife to cut it in 3's? Don't order that for sure. Calamari breaded well tender but again NO FLAVOR
Be the first to ReplyStopped in for dinner on a Thursday and was instantly
Stopped in for dinner on a Thursday and was instantly charmed by the attentive and courteous staff! The whole place was spotless and beautiful. Some places make you feel like you're somewhere else, Cosimo's makes you believe you've stepped into Italy for dinner. I had tomatoes alla vodka and it was divine! The pasta was done JUST right, and the sauce was perfect!
Be the first to ReplyStarted around 4:15 pm bunch of empty tables, waited to be
Started around 4:15 pm bunch of empty tables, waited to be seated for over 30 minutes in a half empty restaurant.. finally sat down waited another 13 minutes for a menu.. at this point I don't even know why I'm staying? I have been disappointed the last 3 times and I get it there is no where else to go, and why they get away with poor quality in food and performance.. sorry not sorry .. I said it .. it's also very confusing to be Italian , it's not very Italian and it's never consistent always comes out different and if the cook doesn't know they usually dump about a half pound of grated parmigiana on it.. you never know who's going to cook it which way .. never enough sauce dry pasta dishes like eating a plate of chalk. I've wasted enough time on this place .. Bar is always good but under staffed .. only way to get through it is drink .. a lot and drink some more .. you'll think everything is good
Be the first to ReplyAlways a lovely time.
Tonight it was very busy and full. Parking lot was full and sone jackoff parked right at the curb where cars loop to another row blocking and handicapped cars from backing out. It's many 2 person tables so it can feel very cramped. Our server was absolutely chatty and personable. Didn't do apps cos I knew the main was gonna be big. The sausage and ricotta fusilli came home for seconds. They have good crème brûlée and their raspberry sorbet is absolutely stunning.
Be the first to ReplyI have been going to Cosimo's in Newburgh for years and
I have been going to Cosimo's in Newburgh for years and many times I am happy but not always. Same with their Middletown location which is nicer than Middletown but the staff can also be self absorbed and living in their cell phones while ignoring the customers. This location was massive had a great layout. From the moment we were created until we sat down they were on top of their hospitality. Very welcoming and happy to see you there. We sat down and ate and the food was incredible. The prices were very reasonable compared to other places in the area. This is the cosimos I love and I will be coming here a lot even though there is one in Newburgh I'm 5 minutes away from. I don't mind driving to where there is good service and good food. Tom our waiter was super on top of his service game and made some very intelligent recommendations to us. What else would you expect from a former cobra commander. Inside joke between Tom and I. We will be back at least once a week.
Be the first to ReplyCame here for dinner and had a pleasant experience.
This is a modern Italian restaurant that adds some flair to some classic recipes. The food portions are decently sized and the food is pretty decent as well. The sauce is a little chunky and I prefer a smoother sauce. The service itself is good and the waiters are attentive. The restaurant is gorgeous and spacious. It even has a room upstairs for private events.
Be the first to ReplyAwesome Flatbread.
definitely will be back. Went up when visiting my son at the CIA and this place was the BEST
Be the first to ReplyWhat a lovely lunch! It's a very pretty place with many
What a lovely lunch! It's a very pretty place with many windows, making it very bright. Our waitress JoJo was professional, pleasant, checking on us frequently. We all ordered pizza, they were very delicious and came pipping hot to the table. Personal pizza are quite big for one person, we all had left over half a pizza. My friend had a gluten free crust and she liked it. We definitely will go back. Unfortunately no room for desert. The table next to us had Carrot Cakes that look so very yummy. They actually told us, they would recommend it. We most definitely will go back
Be the first to ReplyWe came here while visiting the area on a Saturday night.
This place was average and your stereotypical Italian chain restaurant. It was pretty packed but we got seated quickly and they have a bar inside & tv screens for you to watch the game. The service overall was good and super quick. They provide some bread & olive oil + balsamic vinegar for you to nibble on which was nice. In terms of food, we got the spicy chicken fusilli pasta and nick's pie. The pasta was interesting... they garnished the dish with scallions which seemed super weird and did not compliment the dish and the chicken was not good. It tasted very rubbery but the overall pasta itself was good and the sauce had good flavor. The pizza was very underwhelming because the dough was undercooked. The pizza was super soggy so it was falling apart when we picked it up and the flavors just weren't it. For dessert, we got the warm chocolate lava cake which had a coffee crunch ice cream and it was good! A solid lava cake. Overall, not super impressed and if you're visiting town, I would recommend trying somewhere else instead.
Be the first to ReplyI'm often invited here for work functions as I work at
I'm often invited here for work functions as I work at Marist. There's always folks here and the botchi out side is a cool feature. The place is beautiful inside and out. The bar is super nice and there's tons of corners and private areas for an intimate feeling. The food is always super delicious the servers are always super knowledgeable. Everything I've ever had is seasoned well and well garnished. I've actually never had anything I was. It super happy with! I'd definitely recommend this place to anyone. Super good drinks and service too!
Be the first to ReplyThe food is excellent.
The ambiance and the service is always great too. The staff is always so friendly and courteous.
Be the first to ReplyGreat local food with excellent service.
One of my favorite places to eat at in my town.
Be the first to ReplyThe food is always great.
The atmosphere is nice. The staff is always friendly, pleasant and helpful. I have food allergies, but they have good substitutions.
Be the first to ReplyDefinitely one of the most authentic Italian restaurants
Definitely one of the most authentic Italian restaurants I've been in the food was so good. I went on my sister's birthday. The very nice high ceilings and it had a very home like feeling. Loved it. I would like to come here on my birthday in June. The service was fast and our waiter was really nice.
Be the first to ReplyAs a local resident I dine here often.
I'm never disappointed. I LOVE the honey ginger salad. Just great flavor. Rigatoni Buttera is probably my favorite pasta dish although I haven't tried them all. Spicy Chicken Fusilli is another favorite. The mozz sticks are by far the best I've had. The only negative I can say is about the women's bathroom. Not food related obviously, but I would love to see the restaurant put some money into it. Change the doors. They're dirty and falling apart a bit. Fresh coat of paint can make a big difference. Also, the most recent time I was there it clearly needed cleaning. The garbage was overflowing.
Be the first to ReplyBad service, staff doesn't care and is rude/stuck up and
Bad service, staff doesn't care and is rude/stuck up and you cant just go up and pay, they seem to have a bad system in place. Maybe get takeout? But the nice atmosphere inside is a lie.
Be the first to ReplyAfter passing it dozens of times, we finally gave it a try.
Had a group of 8, and service was efficient and friendly (Matt was our server). The menu is wide-ranging, with lots of pasta selections, pizzas, and meals. Appetizer selection was also great. Everyone enjoyed the fried calamari and the family-style antipasto. Based on a recommendation from Matt, I had the 8-hour pork cacciatore which was excellent, served with a creamy polenta. Reasonable prices as well.
Be the first to ReplyI don't think I really need to recommend this place.
I think we've all been there by now. Everything is always great. The waffle rosemary fries w/ Gorgonzola cream are not to be missed(I recommend you get the sauce on the side and dip to avoid sogginess). The long pepper and sausage pizza is hard to pass up and I crave it. The snapper puttanesca w/ creamy polenta & Brussels sprouts is a delicious healthy option. Finally, lemon tartuffo w/ a double espresso, chefs kiss.
Be the first to ReplyI'm so glad there are spots like Cosimo's in the Hudson
I'm so glad there are spots like Cosimo's in the Hudson Valley. We planned out our day with our hotel concierge. After we finished our walk over the Hudson, we made our way to have lunch at Cosimo's.Walking into the space, its very large! I see a big pizza oven, Cosimo's is making their dough on premise for their breads and pizzas. It's lunch, I dont want to eat too heavy so my wife & I split a salad as well as the Prosciutto and Fig Flatbread.The Prosciutto and Fig Flatbread, amazing flavors! Touched with a hot of balsamic vinegar, this was a great starter.The Toscano Pear Salad was enough to share. The salad had sliced pear, toasted walnut, cranberries, shaved Pecorino Toscano and tossed in a Prosecco Vinaigrette. Perfecto!We each had a glass of Italian wine, this was the perfect lunch to finish up a perfect afternoon.Cosimo's is in the heart of the Poughkeepsie business district. It was a great spot to visit during our stay in Hudson Valley.
Be the first to ReplyI stopped on my last day vacationing in Poughkeepsie.
It's a large space with a great staff. The pizzas and the pastas are great. Portion sizes are on the bigger size. When I'm back in Poughkeepsie I will definitely will be coming back.
Be the first to ReplyThe sauce ! the meatballs! I can't say what I like best
The sauce ! the meatballs! I can't say what I like best because I love them both! it's good every time.
Be the first to ReplyThis place is the go to Italian place in PoughkeepsieWe got
This place is the go to Italian place in PoughkeepsieWe got here around 1:30 and the restaurant is packed. They give us a table in the corner of the back room and Rick comes right over. We order Two glasses of house cab. It's Lent so it's no meat for us!I can't really assess the full scope of the place because of this abstinence from meat. The calamari jumps out at us so we order that first. It comes and it's crispy and absolutely delicious. Not at all greasy. Just perfect !We order two pizzas margarita and another cheese pizza, the name of which escapes me We chat, haven't seen each other in five months. My friend is a bronze sculptor, specializing in ecclesiastical themes. Saints and such. Amazing artist he is. Another glass is ordered as I've commissioned him to create a small bronze of God holding Adam and Eve. Something I've been intrigued with for a long time. To top things off we order a lemon cake and espresso. What a perfect Friday afternoon lunch.
Be the first to ReplyI got here at 9:10pm, 50 minutes before "closing" and the
I got here at 9:10pm, 50 minutes before "closing" and the host told us the kitchen was closed. False advertisement that they stay open until 10. We even offered to grab takeout and were still denied. This is one of the few places in Poughkeepsie that advertises that they stay open until 10, when in fact the kitchen closes around 9. Major disappointment!
Be the first to ReplyGreat authentic Italian food.
The sauce is fresh and superb. The mozzarella is a perfect hand made product. Great atmosphere and service. The best!
Be the first to ReplyIt was about 5PM on a Thursday when my party of three first
It was about 5PM on a Thursday when my party of three first arrived and we were seated right away, no wait. The interior is beautifully decorated giving the restaurant an upscale feel. The only critique to the interior I'd say is that the tables are very close together making the dining room feel less private and a little overwhelming.We were given bread and olive oil to nosh on as we waited for our meals. Although the wait time was literally under five minutes after we ordered. We were shocked when they brought out our food so quick!I have a dairy allergy and they were very accommodating and knowledgeable about their menu items and what I could eat. I order the pasta Al Pomodoro with grilled chicken. (Not necessarily an exact menu item but I was able to get that custom made which was a treat!) The main reason I took off a star is because I thought the food was average. The pasta sauce is very sweet and not very well seasoned in my opinion. Other than that I had a lovely time here and was happy overall with my experience.
Be the first to Reply